The 2009 Ford Mustang lasts around 200,000 miles with only some minor paint and door panel issues. At $6,663 to $34,551, it’s a good value for a powerful and dependable sports car.
Is the 2009 Ford Mustang a Good Used Car?
- Yes, 2009 is a good year for the Mustang. Owner reviews praise the powerful engines, responsive handling, and affordable ownership costs for a sports car.
- Interior quality is average compared to other sports cars, but the high-end models have some nice materials, and the technology is very good for its age.
- Reliability ratings are above average. Mustang models from 2008–2011 are good choices, with more issues showing up in 2012.
- Performance is average from the standard V6 engine, but the larger V8 engines offer excellent power.
- The 2009 Mustang is a safe sports car getting a perfect overall 5-star rating in government crash tests, and only getting 4 stars in rear passenger side crash tests.
- Fuel economy is good for a sports car, averaging around 20 MPG, which will get owners about 320 miles of range out of the 16 gallon fuel tank.
Positive Owner Reviews
Negative Owner Reviews
What Do Critics Say About the Ford Mustang?
- Consumer Reports says the Mustang is an excellent sports car, with above-average owner satisfaction scores.
- Edmunds gives the Mustang a 4.7/5 praising the powerful V8 engines, but doesn’t like the lack of stability control.
- Kelley Blue Book users rate the Mustang 4.7/5 and enjoy the relatively affordable performance, but owners don’t like the cramped rear seats.
What Common Problems Does the 2009 Ford Mustang Have?
The most common complaints from owners on the 2009 Ford Mustang include bubbling paint, broken door panels, and a cracked thermostat housing. Overall, these problems are very minor compared to other sports cars from 2009.
Bubbling paint is the most common issue reported by owners at around 45,000 miles. The paint on the hood starts to fail and bubble up as the car ages and is exposed to a lot of sunlight. Repainting the hood fixes the problem, and costs about $800.
Broken door panels are another issue on the 2009 Mustang at around 40,000 miles. The glue that holds the door panels together is weak and wears out as the door is opened and closed. Re-gluing the panel is easy and costs about $20 for materials, or new panels are roughly $300 per door.
A cracked thermostat housing on the engine shows up on some Mustang models at around 80,000 miles. The housing is made of plastic and cracks as it heats and cools. Replacing the housing is an affordable job, costing about $250.
There are 7 recalls, average compared to other sports cars from 2009. All of the recalls are for air bag inflators, and are not a concern once they have been replaced for free.
How Long Will the 2009 Ford Mustang Last?
A well-maintained 2009 Ford Mustang should be able to last around 200,000 miles, which is about 50,000 miles more than rivals like the Dodge Challenger. Regular annual maintenance costs are similar to other sports cars according to Repair Pal at $658 per year.
Since most 2009 Mustang models will have over 100,000 miles buyers should be prepared to replace items including the alternator for $450, fuel sending unit costing $900, and the power steering hoses which cost $300.
I wouldn't recommend buying this car. I believe that there are way too many other cars that are better
How Much Is the 2009 Ford Mustang Worth?
Blue book values range from $6,663 to $34,551, making it thousands of dollars cheaper than a Nissan 370z or Dodge Challenger. The pricing varies since the Shelby GT500 is a low-production model. When new, the price range was $20,430 to $33,985. Depreciation is better than average, only losing about 7% of its current value per year.
What are the Different Models of the Ford Mustang?
There are five models of the mustang available for the 2009 model year. The fifth generation of the Mustang was introduced in 2005, with the sixth generation launching in 2015.
Deluxe is the entry-level model and has:
- 16-Inch Alloy Wheels
- Cloth Seating
- Keyless Entry
- Cruise Control
- AM/FM/CD Stereo System With 3.5mm AUX
Premium is a step up, adding:
- Unique 16-Inch Wheels
- Power Driver’s Seat
- Shaker 500 Stereo With 6-CD Stereo System
GT Deluxe has a V8 engine and adds:
- 17-Inch Alloy Wheels
- Performance Seats
- Upgraded Cloth Sating
- Fog Lights
- Rear Spoiler
GT Premium offers more features including:
- Leather Seating
- New 17-Inch Alloy Wheels
- Suspension Improvements
- Shaker 1000 Stereo
Shelby GT500 is the performance model with:
- 18-Inch Alloy Wheels
- Shelby Leather & Suede Interior
- MacPherson Suspension
- Limited Slip Rear Differential
- Xenon Headlights
What Engines Come In the Ford Mustang?
- The base engine is an average 4.0L V6 which makes 210 horsepower and gets up to 20 MPG combined.
- A step up is the stronger 4.6L V8 which produces 315 horsepower while getting up to 18 MPG combined.
- The flagship engine is the powerful 5.4L supercharged V8 which makes 500 horsepower and gets up to 16 MPG combined. Performance is excellent, taking 4.6 seconds to go from 0-60 MPH.
What Colors Does the Ford Mustang Come In?
How Big Is the Ford Mustang?
The 2009 Ford Mustang is an average sized 2-door sports car offered as coupe and convertible and is bigger than other sports cars like the Honda S2000 and Mazda Miata. Passenger room is good in the front seats, but the backseats are very cramped and not good for long drives.
Cargo space is above average in the coupe with 13.1 cubic feet of room, but the convertible is small with only 9.7 cubic feet of space. That’s enough room for 3-4 suitcases in the coupe and 2-3 in the convertible.
How Does the Ford Mustang Compare to the Competition?
The 2009 Ford Mustang is a very good sports car offering fewer mechanical problems than other high-horsepower rivals.
The Nissan 370z is a rival that costs about $5,000 more. Steering feel and interior materials are nicer in the Nissan 370z, but the Ford Mustang has more powerful V8 engines available. We recommend the Ford Mustang since they’re more fun to drive, and more affordable to own.
The Chevrolet Corvette is another American sports car which costs $10,000 more. Performance and handling are both better in the Chevy Corvette, but the Ford Mustang has more space in the cabin. We recommend the Chevy Corvette for a weekend car, but the Ford Mustang is easier to live with as a daily driver.
Do Owners Recommend the Ford Mustang?
Sure but it is rather tiny inside drives like a champion so smooth on the road gas mileage is pretty good for a sport car