More expensive than other compact cars ranging from $6,959 to $10,358, the 2009 is a bad choice with more complaints than any other year. Common engine problems and water pump failures give the Corolla a shorter lifespan than normal, at only 200,000 miles.
2009 Toyota Corolla: Quick Overview
- 2009 is the first model year for the tenth generation of the Corolla with all-new engines, exterior, and interior choices.
- We rate the 2009 Toyota Corolla’s reliability as poor, even though J.D. Power gave it a great rating when the car was new. Engine and air conditioning problems are common as the car ages.
- Two engine choices are available. Both are 4-cylinders but the larger one found in the XRS model has good power for the class.
- Fuel economy is good, ranking 3rd out of 30 compact cars from 2009 with a combined rating of up to 30 miles per gallon.
- Safety ratings are good for a small car, getting 4 out of 5 stars in government crash tests and earning a Top Safety Pick Award from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.
- The 2009 Toyota Corolla ranks 13th out of 30 compact cars based on owner reviews. The 2009 model year has more problems than other years, and is one buyers should avoid.
Expert Ratings
Positive Owner Reviews
Negative Owner Reviews
What Problems Does the 2009 Toyota Corolla Have?
There are more problems with the 2009 Toyota Corolla than any other year, and a lot of them are serious mechanical issues. Big improvements arrive for the 2011 model, making the $1,800 price difference worth the cost.
Engine problems including excessive oil consumption and noise from the engine, are both mentioned by owners at around 100,000 miles. Toyota engines commonly consume more oil than other cars, but the 2009 Corolla has a problem with the piston rings making the problem worse. Checking the oil regularly is important since engine failures can occur if the oil level is too low, costing over $4,000 to replace.
Water pump failures are very common with the 2009 model at around 60,000 miles. The water pump moves coolant through the engine, and when it fails there’s a risk of overheating. Replacing the water pump costs about $850, depending on local labor rates.
Paint defects are another common issue, with failures happening after about 5 years. Paint tends to have issues when the curing process fails, or when the paint is exposed to excessive sunlight. The only solution is repainting the affected panels, costing over $800 per panel.
There are 13 recalls, which is more than other compact cars from the same year. The recalls include brake vacuum ports, accelerator pedals, load-carrying labels, power window switches, air bags, and seat heater wiring. Most serious are pedal problems which may cause unintended acceleration.
How Much is the 2009 Toyota Corolla Worth?
Ranging in price from $6,959 to $10,358, depending on the model and mileage, the 2009 Toyota Corolla is more expensive than other compact cars including the Mazda3 and Civic. When new, the price range was $15,350 to $20,050. Depreciation on the used market is average for the class, losing about 10% of the current value each year.
What Are the Models & Specs?
Base is the stripped down entry-level model with:
- 15-inch Steel Wheels
- Power Mirrors
- Air Conditioning
- AM/FM/CD Stereo with AUX Jack
LE is next in the lineup and adds:
- Power Windows
- Power Locks
- Body Colored Exterior Trim
S is an upgrade adding:
- 16-inch Steel Wheels
- New Front and Rear Bumpers
- Fog Lights
- Sport Seating
- Leather Steering Wheel
XLE is a luxurious version with improvements including:
- 16-inch Alloy Wheels
- Leather Seating
- Wood Interior Trim
- Keyless Entry
XRS is the most fun as a performance-oriented model with:
- A Larger Engine
- 17-Inch Alloy Wheels
- Sport Suspension
- Rear Deck Spoiler
How Long Will the 2009 Toyota Corolla Last?
A properly cared for 2009 Toyota Corolla will last about 200,000 miles, which is shorter than other years for the model. Repair Pal estimates regular annual maintenance costs to be average for the class, similar to the Civic and Elantra, at $384 per year.
As the 2009 Corolla reaches 100,000 miles, there are a few maintenance items owners may need to address. They include brake master cylinders for $500, steering knuckles for about $600, and A/C condenser costing $550.
I have oil changes every 5,000 miles. It has not needed a lot of maintenance. Body has held together nicely.
Yes, my 2009 corolla s is very reliable. I travel approximately 17500 miles a year and I can always depend on my little red corolla to get me to my destinations smoothly and problem free. Other than self imposed issues, the corolla s if quite problem free.
I haven't had any problems with mine and I have had it for 10 years. Do not expect any problems in the near future either.
Toyota vehicles are always reliable. Knock on wood, things have been good. Minor issues that come up with normal wear and tear of car (ie. Belt needed to be replaced after 80k miles).
Yes. No problems. Never had any problems with my vehicle. Has performed very good. Reliable and dependable. Drive it daily and it runs like a dream.
I have only had one problem with this vehicle and it was a big one the transmission went out at 140,000 miles which I had to replace.
It is very reliable. Being that the car is ten years old, now any and every problem you can think is noticeable.
Yes it is so reliable. Bought it with about 30k miles on it. Have not had one bit of trouble with it. Even last year when parked outside and we had -30 degrees cold blast. Only thing I have had to do is regular maintenance like oil changes, and 60k, 90k, 120k regular check ups.
What Technology & Safety Features Are Included?
Technology in the Toyota Corolla is good for the class and the updated 2009 model has more features than the outgoing version.
- Standard features include a 4-speaker stereo system with AM/FM/CD playback, and a 3.5mm AUX port.
- Optional upgrades include a 7-inch touchscreen infotainment system, navigation, and an improved 6-speaker stereo system.
- Safety features include air bags and antilock brakes. Stability control is standard on the XRS model.
What Engine Options are Available?
Performance in the 2009 Toyota Corolla is better than some competitors. The XRS model with the upgraded engine takes only 7.9 seconds to go from 0 to 60 miles per hour.
- The base engine is a 1.8L 4-cylinder with 132 horsepower.
- An upgraded 2.4L 4-cylinder is available in the XRS model with 152 horsepower.
What Color Options are Available?
How Big is the Corolla?
The 2009 Toyota Corolla is a compact car and is similar in size to other cars in the same class like the Civic and Sentra. Passenger room in the backseats of the car is acceptable, but not class leading, and some adults may feel cramped. Cargo space is average for the class, fitting 3 to 4 suitcases in the 12.3 cubic foot trunk.
How Does the 2009 Toyota Corolla Compare to Other Cars?
Ranking 13th out of 30 compact cars, based on owner reviews, the 2009 Toyota Corolla is in the middle of the class.
A higher rated competitor is the more affordable Mazda3. Where the Mazda stands out is with fewer complaints from owners, and more practicality with the optional hatchback. On the other hand, the Corolla has more technology available, and better fuel economy. For the 2009 model year, the Mazda3 is a better choice, with less serious problems.
Another close rival is the Honda Civic, which is in the same price range. The Civic has better interior materials, and offers a sportier driving experience. Where the Corolla comes out ahead is with a more comfortable suspension, and more up-to-date technology. Overall, 2009 is a bad model year for both cars, and we do not recommend either of them to shoppers.
Final Verdict: Is the 2009 Toyota Corolla a Good Car?
No, the 2009 Toyota Corolla is not a good car. Although there’s a combined rating of 4.2/5 based on 542 verified owner reviews, we have found serious engine issues affecting the long-term reliability. The positives include a more comfortable driving experience than rivals, and a long list of standard features. Where the Corolla misses the mark is with more problems than other years, and the electronic steering feels disconnected. Overall, 2009 is a model year to avoid, with the 2011 version being a much better choice for buyers looking for a Corolla.
Yes. It has been a great vehicle. Easy to drive, car corners well, has good pickup, and has not needed a lot of maintenance.
Yes, the 2009 corolla s has proven to be extremely reliable, gas friendly, and very comfortable. The only issue I have is that given it is a s trim, the bumpers are very low and near the ground requiring careful parking and careful attention to potholes.
Yes, reliable, parts are affordable. Great mileage, compact and easy to street park. Great for road trips.
Yes, I have owned my vehicle for 7 years. It was purchased pre-owned with 20k miles. It is a quality car that retains much of its value over time. The drive is smooth and the gas mileage is great.
Yes the best. Very little maintenance needed to date. Good gas mileage and drives great. Love the way it handles in snow.
Yes it is very good for the base model of a corolla but could use at least power windows in this case.
Yes it is the second best car I have ever owned. I have also owned a 2005 Toyota corolla.They're great on mileage.
Yes it is a great car. Has around 140k miles on it and still drives like a new one. Bought it due to at that time a long drive to work, since then I have moved closer and not putting on as many miles. Has been extremely dependable and leaving in Minnesota it handles very well in the snow. Better than the tundra truck we own. It is easy to maintain, just a basic not luxury car but so dependable.